Today, I was watching a news in the morning, It was all about MMRCA deal of the Indian Air Force. As we all know that India has finalized Rafale as the required aircraft. However, things are not moving ahead and there are many things in the deal on which no agreement is there between India and France. And now, US is trying to enter (with F/A - 18 Super Hornet), and offering lots of other things like Making in India, ToT (I guess so) etc. Well, this blog is not about the nitty-gritty of the deal but its about how our Media covers the news.
First of all, in my opinion, barring a handful of reporters, none in Media has the capability to cover a defence related news properly. And those handful of reporters are either retired Armed forces personnel or the dependents who have lived their lives along with their fathers/mothers and saw this world very closely.
We should understand that Defence world is TOTALLY DIFFERENT from the civil world; everything related to love, life and profession is different; and many of it is classified too. My father is in the armed forces and once I asked him (like a Journalist) about his work; he politely said, "You don't need to know much. Mind your on bloody business!".........tough being a defence kid.
Anyways, I was saying that many part of Defence is classified and outside world (including Media) don't know. So, how media covers the defence related news in India. As per my opinion they also don't know how to cover the news. So, they get 30% data, repeat it 2-3 times and put "bullshit" (including images and videos which they show in the news) in the remaining time. E.g., In the news, which I am taking about, the reporter was talking about the Rafale; it was the same content (one line), presented 3 times in 3 different ways; and on the top of that, never ever they showed Rafale fighter jet in the video; instead, F-16 and Gripen were shown (there is a huge difference between them); along with a small clip of F-16 from PAF (flag and insignia was visible). Does media have any idea what and how to present while covering defence news? I doubt. This is not the first time when this screw-up has happened. In one news, report was taking about T-90 tanks and in the video clip it was showing T-72 tanks, and in one clip they showed Abram Tanks (of US).
And in one clip, they reached the height of insanity and ignorance: I remember, few years back, a Jaguar fighter aircraft had crashed (luckily pilot had survived) and the report was trying to cover the news. They still didn't have access to the crash site, so they were showing a MiG-21 crashsite video (you can easily make out by looking at the Tail and Wings design). Now, the report tried to interview the then spokesperson of the IAF. He asked how this fighter plane crashed. The Spokesperson said that they are investigating the matter and a Court of Inquiry has been setup. After some times, he asks "How many passengers were there in the aircraft?".........what!!!!! it wasn't a transport aircraft Sir! it was a fighter aircraft.
Well, lots of screw-up Media has done while covering Defence related news; and they continue to do so. Why? (I think) because:
1. These Media people don't do homework before covering the news
2. They think, we common civil people don't know much about the defence; so dikhao kuch bhi, kya farak padta hai
As a media person, they should understand that there is a huge responsibility on their shoulders, as they are the eyes and ears of the common people. People will believe what they will say and show. "With great power comes great responsibilities"
You should understand the difference between IAF and PAF; Rafale, F-16, Gripen and MiG-35; MiG-29 and Su-30 MKI; you just can't put any video/image on the screen while talking. Please do some homework and don't just put any nonsense just to become "first to broadcast".
Well, I can only hope that media people get their acts together. But by looking at their current performance, I feel they "Don't care a damn" about the quality of stuff. They just throw things on the screen and do some "Charcha" or "Debate" calling people from different sections, and make a Machchi Market (Fish market) out of it. They just love making and spreading crap. And, on the top of it, you see one news channel supporting something which is opposed by another news channel. And we people keep flipping channels, and enjoy the show (especially debate) which, I feel, is far better than "Comedy night with Kapil". Was this the probable reason why Kapil decided to close the program - I don't know.
First of all, in my opinion, barring a handful of reporters, none in Media has the capability to cover a defence related news properly. And those handful of reporters are either retired Armed forces personnel or the dependents who have lived their lives along with their fathers/mothers and saw this world very closely.
We should understand that Defence world is TOTALLY DIFFERENT from the civil world; everything related to love, life and profession is different; and many of it is classified too. My father is in the armed forces and once I asked him (like a Journalist) about his work; he politely said, "You don't need to know much. Mind your on bloody business!".........tough being a defence kid.
Anyways, I was saying that many part of Defence is classified and outside world (including Media) don't know. So, how media covers the defence related news in India. As per my opinion they also don't know how to cover the news. So, they get 30% data, repeat it 2-3 times and put "bullshit" (including images and videos which they show in the news) in the remaining time. E.g., In the news, which I am taking about, the reporter was talking about the Rafale; it was the same content (one line), presented 3 times in 3 different ways; and on the top of that, never ever they showed Rafale fighter jet in the video; instead, F-16 and Gripen were shown (there is a huge difference between them); along with a small clip of F-16 from PAF (flag and insignia was visible). Does media have any idea what and how to present while covering defence news? I doubt. This is not the first time when this screw-up has happened. In one news, report was taking about T-90 tanks and in the video clip it was showing T-72 tanks, and in one clip they showed Abram Tanks (of US).
And in one clip, they reached the height of insanity and ignorance: I remember, few years back, a Jaguar fighter aircraft had crashed (luckily pilot had survived) and the report was trying to cover the news. They still didn't have access to the crash site, so they were showing a MiG-21 crashsite video (you can easily make out by looking at the Tail and Wings design). Now, the report tried to interview the then spokesperson of the IAF. He asked how this fighter plane crashed. The Spokesperson said that they are investigating the matter and a Court of Inquiry has been setup. After some times, he asks "How many passengers were there in the aircraft?".........what!!!!! it wasn't a transport aircraft Sir! it was a fighter aircraft.
Well, lots of screw-up Media has done while covering Defence related news; and they continue to do so. Why? (I think) because:
1. These Media people don't do homework before covering the news
2. They think, we common civil people don't know much about the defence; so dikhao kuch bhi, kya farak padta hai
As a media person, they should understand that there is a huge responsibility on their shoulders, as they are the eyes and ears of the common people. People will believe what they will say and show. "With great power comes great responsibilities"
You should understand the difference between IAF and PAF; Rafale, F-16, Gripen and MiG-35; MiG-29 and Su-30 MKI; you just can't put any video/image on the screen while talking. Please do some homework and don't just put any nonsense just to become "first to broadcast".
Well, I can only hope that media people get their acts together. But by looking at their current performance, I feel they "Don't care a damn" about the quality of stuff. They just throw things on the screen and do some "Charcha" or "Debate" calling people from different sections, and make a Machchi Market (Fish market) out of it. They just love making and spreading crap. And, on the top of it, you see one news channel supporting something which is opposed by another news channel. And we people keep flipping channels, and enjoy the show (especially debate) which, I feel, is far better than "Comedy night with Kapil". Was this the probable reason why Kapil decided to close the program - I don't know.
I wish our media people were more responsible. I wish they did homework before blabbering in front of the camera. But kaun samjhaaye unn logon ko....